What is the main idea of two ways to belong in America?
What is the main idea of two ways to belong in America?
This story shows the parallelism between what different immigrants think of moving to the United States from their home country. Some embrace the change and are excited to adopt new cultures, while others are scared and wish to hang on to their culture.
What are the 2 ways Mukherjee discusses to belong in America?
Despite both sisters living in America, only Bharati is an American citizen, while her sister Mira is not. Bharati argues the two ways to belong in America are to transform yourself as an immigrant, or to be an exile. Her sister, Mira, hangs on passionately to her Indian lifestyle and hopes return home to retire.
What is the tone of two ways to belong in America?
The tone is frank even as she examines both sides to wanting to adapt to the new environment or retaining one’s culture identity. The use of imagery makes Mukherjee seem very happy living in America and giving up her old culture, which strongly contrasts her sister’s anger towards America and being an immigrant.
What does Mukherjee mean when she says the price that the immigrant willingly pays and the exile avoids is the trauma of self transformation paragraph 15 )?
In the last sentence, the author mentioned that ‘the price that the immigrant willingly pays, and that the exile avoids, is the trauma of self-transformation’. The ‘trauma of self-transformation’ in this context refers to the need to change oneself to fit into the culture of the country one has migrated to.
Which rhetorical appeals and strategies does Mukherjee use in the essay?
Throughout the essay Mukherjee used rhetorical devices such as: compare/contrast, fluency, and tone. She used these in such a way that it was both interesting and easy to read.
How long did Bharati Mukherjee and her sister stay in America?
-This is a tale of two sisters from Calcutta, Mira and Bharati, who lived in the United States for some thirty years, but who find themselves on different sides in the current debate over the status of immigrants.
What does it mean to belong to America?
Belonging in the USA means being accepted within the social fabric of what is a great society.
What is the main argument of Mukherjee’s essay?
The argument Mukherjee makes for becoming a U.S. citizen, is that America spoke to her in ways that India didn’t. She feels the need to be a part of the communities within the United States, in order to try and make her home the best place possible.
What according to Mukherjee is the difference between an immigrant and an exile?
She uses “exile” to refer to immigrants like her sister, who aim to hold onto traditions and practices from their original culture; Mukherjee believes that not aiming for assimilation leads to exile in one’s new country.
How does America still provide access to the American dream?
The American Dream is still accessible because all Americans have a right to have their own idea of happiness and those who strive for it can achieve it. In the Declaration of Independence, it states that all Americans are granted “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness” (Declaration of Independence 59).
How effective is Mukherjee’s conclusion does it summarize the essay major points would another strategy be more effective explain?
Mukherjee’s conclusion is quite effective. She is letting the reader know that despite how these experiences differ, they still ultimately come with the same cost. To stay in America, an immigrant must change themselves in one way or another in order to fit in comfortably.
